Menu Close

Watchdog report cites ‘many failures’ in US efforts to rebuild Afghanistan

An independent watchdog’s report on the reconstruction of Afghanistan in depth the “many failures” above the earlier two a long time, including having difficulties to acquire a coherent technique across governing administration companies, underestimating the Afghans’ ability to sustain American-led jobs, and failing to fully grasp the context on the ground. 

It’s release comes as the Biden administration presides around a widely panned armed forces withdrawal from the war-torn nation that has led to the lightning takeover of the country by the Taliban, a chaotic circumstance at Kabul’s international airport exactly where crowds of Afghans collected in a determined attempt to flee Taliban rule and an evacuation operation that is struggling to fly American citizens out of harm’s way. 

“Twenty decades later on, a lot has enhanced, and a great deal has not,” the report released Tuesday by the Special Inspector Normal for Afghanistan Reconstruction says.

“If the objective was to rebuild and leave at the rear of a nation that can sustain alone and pose minor risk to US national security passions, the over-all image is bleak.”

A Taliban fighter on the back of a truck patrolling the streets of Jalalabad, Afghanistan on August 17, 2021.
Photograph by STRINGER/EPA-EFE/Shutte

It stated the authorities was prosperous in some spots – expanding health care, higher literacy charges and reduce child mortality rates — but “progress has been elusive and the prospective customers for sustaining this progress are dubious.”

“The U.S. govt has been generally overwhelmed by the magnitude of rebuilding a place that, at the time of the U.S. invasion, had now observed two decades of Soviet occupation, civil war, and Taliban brutality,” the report mentioned.

“But soon after shelling out 20 yrs and $145 billion making an attempt to rebuild Afghanistan, the U.S. federal government has numerous lessons it desires to discover. Employing these significant lessons will save lives and avert waste, fraud, and abuse in Afghanistan, and in long run reconstruction missions in other places all around the earth,” the report, titled “What We Require to Learn: Lessons from Twenty Decades of Afghanistan Reconstruction, concluded.

Afghan people gathered outside of the Hamid Karzai International Airport to attempt to flee the country on August 17, 2021.
Afghan people today gathered outdoors of the Hamid Karzai Worldwide Airport to attempt to flee the region on August 17, 2021.
Image by STRINGER/EPA-EFE/Shutte

The report, composed by special inspector John Sopko, based its assessment on 13 many years of oversight function, 760 interviews SIGAR workers done with previous and current policymakers, ambassadors, armed forces officers and advancement experts. 

The SIGAR report pointed out that the US authorities expended $145 billion around the two a long time to rebuild Afghanistan, its safety forces, federal government establishments and society. 

And the Defense Office expended $837 billion on battling the war in which 2,443 American troops have been killed and 20,666 have been wounded. 

“The remarkable expenses were meant to provide a function – even though the definition of that function evolved above time,” the report said. 

Displaced women and children in a mosque in Kabul on August 13, 2021.
Displaced gals and youngsters in a mosque in Kabul on August 13, 2021.
Picture by Paula Bronstein /Getty

People at any time-evolving plans included eradicating al-Qaeda, decimating the Taliban, denying terrorists a risk-free haven in Afghanistan to plot attacks on the US and its allies by developing the Afghan safety forces, and bolstering the civilian govt.

But the rebuilding effort was hampered by the US placing aims that sacrificed very long-time period gains for limited-expression successes. 

The US govt “consistently underestimated the total of time needed to rebuild Afghanistan and made unrealistic timelines and expectations that prioritized paying out quickly” but led to incomplete effects.

“Billions of reconstruction dollars had been squandered as jobs went unused or fell into disrepair. Needs to make quickly development incentivized U.S. officers to identify and apply limited-phrase initiatives with minor thing to consider for host government ability and extensive-phrase sustainability. U.S. businesses had been seldom judged by their projects’ continued utility, but by the range of tasks concluded and pounds expended,” the 140-site report mentioned.

A militant raising the Taliban flag in Kandahar, Afghanistan on August 17, 2021.
A militant raising the Taliban flag in Kandahar, Afghanistan on August 17, 2021.
Image by STRINGER/EPA-EFE/Shutte

The US also failed to grasp rampant corruption in the state, a flaw that undermined the overall mission. 

“U.S. systems empowered malign actors and exacerbated preexisting inequities, undermining the legitimacy of the Afghan authorities they were supposed to bolster,” the report mentioned.

Previous US Ambassador to Afghanistan Ryan Crocker is quoted in the report: “The top place of failure for our efforts was not an insurgency. It was the pounds of endemic corruption.”

Supply link