Menu Close

Judge rejects man’s self-defense claim for pulling gun on black teens

A Florida decide denied an “angry” white man’s self-defense assert for pulling a gun on a group of black young children when yelling racial slurs in the course of a heated Martin Luther King Jr. Day confrontation.

A Miami-Dade choose declined Thursday to dismiss the superior-profile situation towards Mark Bartlett, who was caught on digicam erupting on the black teens protesting a lack of reasonably priced housing as they blocked website traffic in downtown Miami on Jan. 21, 2019, the Miami Herald noted.

“The use of racial comments exhibits he was simmering,” Judge Alberto Milian claimed just after Bartlett’s two-day Stand Your Ground listening to. “He was an indignant gentleman. He was inconvenienced. He wanted to go back again to Broward County. There was no reasonable justification.”

Cellphone footage showed Bartlett, 54, furiously shouting at the small children, some of whom were reportedly as young as 11, immediately after having out of his Range Rover when driving with his fiancée, Dana Scalione, as they were being caught in website traffic.

“Get the f–k out of right here, you f–king piece of s–t,” Bartlett stated to 1 teen just after one more allegedly ran above Scalione’s foot with his bike. “F–king silly n—ers! F–king dumb-ass f–king n—ers!”

Mark Bartlett is struggling with 5 felony fees, together with three expenses of aggravated assault with a firearm.

Other footage introduced to court docket this 7 days confirmed Bartlett, of Broward County, shouting “N—ers suck!” 3 periods. He explained to Milian he was only responding to the young gentlemen on bicycles who referred to as him a “cracker,” the Herald described.

“It’s not a thing I am proud of,” Bartlett testified. “I regretably stooped to his degree. I cannot acquire it back again. I didn’t imply anything. The text by themselves do not imply something. It was just me enjoying tit for tat.”

But Milian was unmoved by Bartlett’s rationalization that he was being “held hostage” against his will throughout the confrontation, indicating he should’ve known as cops.

“You could see he was hazardous,” a person of the teens, who was 16 at the time of the encounter, testified Monday. “I was in shock. I ain’t know what to do.”

Bartlett claimed he was protecting Scalione from a mob of teenagers who have been bordering her, not because they had been trapped in targeted traffic. But Milian ruled the footage showed the teens weren’t an fast danger. A jury demo has been established for Dec. 6, the Herald reported.

Bartlett is dealing with three counts of aggravated assault with a firearm that is enhanced by Florida’s dislike crime law, as perfectly as carrying a hid weapon and poor exhibition of a firearm.

Bartlett instructed Milian he experienced the gun with him at the time “in scenario I needed it,” WPLG described. He pleaded not responsible to the 5 felony charges in February 2019, according to the station.

Bartlett’s legal professional acknowledged the “hateful” racial slurs hurled by his client, but said he was fearful of what could’ve happened next through the confrontation, the Herald reported.

Mark Bartlett pulled a gun on a group of black teenagers during a racist tirade against them.
Mark Bartlett pulled a gun on a group of black youngsters in the course of a racist tirade from them.
@dreamdefenders Twitter

“This is terrifying,” lawyer Bruce Lehr explained to the choose. “This is not a war zone. This is a road in a civilized city.”

Prosecutors and lawyers for the little ones associated, in the meantime, mentioned they ended up “very pleased” with Milian’s ruling, WFOR claimed.

“Basically, what the choose dominated was that we’re not heading to allow for folks to incite violence, to victimize and villainize people and then to cry that they are the victims,” claimed lawyer Marwan Porter, who is representing the little ones in the circumstance.

Supply url